I have been stitching with all types of buttonhole stitches for quite some time now. But today, I looked at my buttonhole stitch and said, ‘OK, wait. Why does it look like blanket stitch?’ If you look at it first, you can easily get confessed.
If it looks confusing to me even after 10 years of sewing, imagine the beginners. So, I decided to note down the difference between buttonhole stitch vs blanket stitch.
The main difference is-
The main difference between buttonhole stitch and blanket stitch is that buttonhole stitch has an extra loop, or “purl,” along the edge that provides extra strength and durability.
I know it won’t do. So let’s talk in detail about it.
Points to be noted:
- The main difference between buttonholes and blanket stitches is their sewing technique.
- The buttonhole stitch has purl on its stitch, but the blanket stitch doesn’t.
- The needle goes from up in the blanket stitch and from the back in the buttonhole stitch.
- Blanket stitch is considered more of an embroidery stitch.
Table of Contents
Is Buttonhole Stitch The Same As Blanket Stitch?
No, buttonhole and blanket stitch may look alike at first glance, but they’re a bit different in structure, purpose, and effect. They are actually different types of stitches.
Buttonhole stitch is for a durable edge. If you need a strong, tightly packed line to reinforce edges, especially where there’s likely to be wear—like in buttonholes. It forms a dense row of stitches that grips the fabric edge and keeps it from fraying.
On the other hand,
The blanket stitch has a slightly more relaxed feel. It was originally used to finish the edges of blankets. It’s usually spaced a little farther apart and has an open, decorative edging look.
So, while they might seem similar, each stitch has its unique role depending on the finish you’re after and how much durability you need.
Buttonhole Stitch Vs Blanket Stitch
So, the main difference between buttonhole stitch vs blanket stitch is their sewing technique and uses. But before they make their difference, let’s have a little introduction.
What Is A Blanket Stitch?
A blanket stitch creates an interlocking loop pattern. This sewing stitch is perfect for reinforcing or finishing the raw edge of the fabric. It was initially designed for binding the edges of blankets (hence the name).
This stitch works especially well on thicker fabrics like felt, fleece, or wool. Its versatility is one reason the blanket stitch is so popular. Doing a Double blanket stitch gives a more decorative look.
It prevents fraying on raw fabric edges and adds charm. It’s often used in appliqué, embroidery, and various craft projects where a decorative finish is desired.
What Is A Buttonhole Stitch?
A buttonhole stitch is a looped stitch designed to strengthen buttonholes and prevent the fabric from unraveling. It is the perfect edging stitch because it creates a buttonhole loop and locks everything up.
This stitch creates a dense, closely spaced line that prevents fraying and provides strength. It is ideal for areas that experience wear and tear, like buttonholes on garments.
So, I’m done with the introduction now. Let’s get into how you can tell them apart.
Blanket Stitch Vs Buttonhole Stitch, What Is The Difference ?
The differences between blanket stitch and buttonhole stitch lie in look, sewing technique, and uses. Still, it needs to be clear. Ok, let’s give you a clear idea-
| Feature | Buttonhole Stitch | Blanket Stitch |
| Look | Extra loop (purl) along the edge for durability. | Soft, evenly spaced loops for a rustic finish. |
| Technique | worked right to the left; the needle was up from the wrong side. | Worked left to right; needle down from the right side. |
| Use | Reinforces buttonholes; durable on high-wear areas. | Decorative edge for blankets, quilts, and crafts. |
| Best For | Buttonholes, sturdy edges, detailed embroidery. | Blanket edges, placemats, pillowcases, and decor. |
Look Of Stitch
The buttonhole stitch may look similar to the blanket stitch, but the reality is not it.
Buttonhole stitch has an extra loop, or purl, along the edge. This additional loop helps secure the stitch more firmly and provides extra thread in areas where the buttonhole experiences the most wear. If you ever did buttonhole stitch, then you would know what I’m talking about.
On the other hand,
Blanket stitch has a soft, decorative look with evenly spaced loops along the edge of the fabric. This stitch shines on projects like blankets or quilts where you want that inviting, rustic finish.
Sewing Technique
With a buttonhole stitch, you make a series of closely spaced stitches that loop around the edge of the fabric. It has an extra loop called a purl.
You usually work this stitch from right to left, with the edge facing you. Edges of buttonholes make it stronger. But-
Blanket stitch family creates larger, evenly spaced loops along the edge. This stitch is typically worked from left to right, with the needle going down into the fabric from the right side.
My sewing expert grandma, Manha Soliman, also points out another difference. She said-
‘Between the 2 stitches, note that the blanket stitch’s needlepoint goes down into the fabric from the right side. And the buttonhole stitch’s needle comes up through the fabric from the wrong side.’
Use Of Stitches
Buttonhole stitch and blanket stitch each have their own special uses. How? Well- The buttonhole stitch is mostly used to reinforce buttonholes on clothes.
It has existed since the 16th century, when Italian cutwork was made. It was used for buttonholes. However, the emotions began in the 19th century, when the features of Broderie Anglaise were in the UK and Rococo embroidery in Northern Europe.
Since then, people have tried to experiment with it and come up with some embroidery versions of it. I also tried almost all versions. Some of my favorite types of buttonhole stitches are:
- Wheel Buttonhole Stitch
- Half-wheel buttonhole stitch
- Detached Buttonhole Stitch
- Closed Buttonhole Stitch
- Cross Buttonhole Stitch
With those, you can create some beautiful buttonhole stitch embroidery, no doubt. And about blanket stitch,
Blanket stitch, on the other hand, was originally designed to finish the edges of blankets. It is now commonly used in quilting, appliqué, and craft projects to add that inviting, handmade feel.
You’ll often see blanket stitches on things like placemats, pillowcases, or even fabric-based decor.
So, while buttonhole stitch is ideal for durability, blanket stitch brings warmth and style to thicker edges and decor pieces.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I Use A Blanket Stitch Instead Of A Buttonhole Stitch?
Yes, you can use a blanket stitch in place of a buttonhole stitch for decorative purposes, but it won’t provide the same durability and strength as a buttonhole stitch for areas like buttonholes.
Which Stitch Is Better For Fabric Edges That Might Fray?
Buttonhole Stitch is better for edges that need reinforcement, as it secures the edge more tightly, helping to prevent fraying.
Do Both Stitches Work The Same Way?
No, they differ slightly. Buttonhole stitch is usually worked from right to left, with the edge facing away, and an extra loop (purl) is added. Blanket stitch is often worked from left to right, creating larger loops along the edge without the added purl.
Outro
So yes, if you look closely, there are many differences between buttonhole stitch and blanket stitch. It’s easy to mix them up, but I hope I have helped you tell them apart. So use them in the right place and in the right way on your sewing projects.
Have any more questions? Then don’t hesitate to contact us.
Leave a Reply